Summary:
Who this article is for: College seniors, new grads, and early-career marketers who want to land their first agency job.
Key takeaways:
- Reaching out before you graduate already puts you ahead of most of your classmates.
- Build a real portfolio site on your own domain, and consider learning WordPress along the way.
- Use your student status. Ask for “pick your brain” conversations every week, and end each one by asking who else you should meet.
- The interview is 30 minutes. The follow-up is where you win. Use a one-two punch, and think about a short Loom video.
- To stand out, show value before you’re hired.
What’s inside:
- Why creative work now has to be paired with the numbers
- How to build a portfolio that works for you
- Agency versus in-house, and how to think 10 years out
- A weekly networking routine, including a LinkedIn approach
- The good, better, best framework for interviews and follow-ups
After touring our office with a group of students, a college senior reached out to our CEO, Josh Webber, with one big question. We’ll call her Maya. (Name changed for privacy.)
“I really want to work in an agency,” she told him. “That’s the big goal for me postgrad. What advice would you have for somebody who’s about to graduate and go into the industry?”
Maya is a communications major with emphases in PR and digital and social media, graduating in December. She has worked as a social media marketer at a student-led agency on campus and has done an in-house internship. She’s already sending out applications.
What followed was the kind of advice we wish someone had handed us at graduation. Here’s what Josh shared.
Start With What You Actually Love
Before giving advice, Josh asked where Maya’s passion sits. Her answer was clear: strategy.
“I love building campaigns and creating strategies for companies,” she said. “I think the dream job is some type of strategist doing that.”
She lit up talking about content calendars, planning everything out, and coming up with new ideas for clients.
She was also honest about the hard parts. The early stages with a client, when you’re trying to figure out what they actually want and how they communicate, felt long and difficult. And yes, client calls made her nervous.
On analytics, she was candid: “I’m not a big math girl.” Josh, a self-described creative guy, gets it. But he pushed back a little.
“The truth is, in today’s day and age, creative has to be paired with the numbers. As a creative, it’s like a new playground.”
In the old days, he explained, you’d launch a campaign, wait for sales, and guess whether the image worked. Now you can A/B test two thumbnails and know quickly which one wins. That’s a skill you can learn, and it makes your creative work stronger.
Step One: You’re Already Doing It
Josh’s first piece of advice was simple: graduate. His second was encouragement. The fact that Maya reached out at all told him a lot.
“The fact that you reached out to me, I was like, ‘Yeah, this girl’s got her head on straight.’”
Plenty of students focus only on school and plan to figure out the job part later. Maya was already doing the work.
Step Two: Build a Portfolio That Works for You
Maya had a portfolio site built in Canva. Josh liked it and suggested two upgrades.
Get your own domain. “Everyone should take their personal brand seriously,” Josh said. He pulled up GoDaddy during the call, and Maya’s name was available for a penny for the first year. His warning: don’t get talked into the upsells. You need the domain, not every add-on they offer at checkout.
Try a real website builder. Wix, Squarespace, and WordPress are all worth a look. WordPress is harder, but Josh sees it as a career advantage. He noted that over 40% of websites on the planet run on it.
“If you spend some time on your lunch break learning WordPress, then you go to any agency and say, ‘Yeah, I’m familiar with WordPress.’ They’re going to love you.”
Once your site is live, connect your domain, add your work, your resume, and a few blog posts. Then, when someone on LinkedIn asks for your resume, you can say, “I’ll do you one better,” and send them your site along with a PDF.
Agency or In-House? Think 10 Years Out
Maya leans toward agency life. Josh agreed that’s a smart place to start, with an honest caveat.
“For younger professionals, you’ll learn 10 times more in an agency, but you’ll be three times more stressed.”
His advice is to reverse engineer your career from where you want to be in 10 years. Look for a good, growing agency that does the kind of work you care about. Some agencies are mostly numbers. Others are much closer to creative or branding shops. Know which one you’re walking into.
It’s common, he said, to spend a few years (anywhere from three to eight) at an agency, learn a ton, and then move in-house when you want more work-life balance. At that point, “you’re a rare commodity because you know a lot.”
Step Three: Network Like Crazy While You’re a Student
Josh also shared something he hadn’t mentioned during the office tour: he majored in French and minored in business administration. His point was not to stress too much about your major. What he did well in school was work a lot and meet people.
Students have an advantage most professionals don’t. When a student asks, “Can I pick your brain?” people say yes. When a CEO asks the same thing, people assume a sales pitch is coming.
“Hey, I’m an ambitious young student. Can I pick your brain? That’s such an easy sell.”
“The interview is 30 minutes. The follow-up is where you win.”
Josh suggested a goal of two or three of these conversations a week before graduation. Talk to professors, friends, family, people in your community, and professionals at the agencies you’d love to join. At the end of each conversation, ask who else they can introduce you to.
On LinkedIn specifically, his approach looks like this:
- Connect with intention. Find people at the places you want to work, or alumni from your school. Aim for about a dozen new connections a week.
- Find common ground. A shared school, a shared city, an office you toured, a role you applied for. Anything that gives you a natural opener.
- Curate carefully. Josh admits he accepted every request for years and now has thousands of connections he doesn’t know.
- Engage before you DM. Like and comment on their posts first. Then reach out and ask for a quick conversation.
- Make the ask. End with something like, “Do you or someone you know need someone like me? If so, would you mind making an introduction?”
“You’d be surprised how much people just want to help the next generation,” Josh said.
The Interview Is 30 Minutes. The Follow-Up Is Where You Win.
Before their call, Maya sent Josh a quick confirmation email. He noticed. Then he walked her through a framework he teaches his own team: good, better, best.
Good: Send a confirmation email before the interview. Josh says 90% of people don’t.
Better: In that email, mention that you reviewed their website and have a few questions you’re excited to ask.
That might already be best, Josh said. But the real key is the follow-up. “We tend to overly focus on that 30 minutes.” Interview skills matter, so ask good questions, talk about problems you’ve solved, show your work, and bring energy. But the interview is one short block in a month-long process.
His follow-up is a one-two punch:
- Right after the call: A thank-you email. Reattach your resume and mention a question or moment that stood out.
- A day or two later: A second note that builds on something they said. By then, hiring managers are sorting through a pile of candidates, and this puts you back on top.
“It’s marketing, you know.”
For extra credit, Josh recommends Loom. The free version lets you record up to five minutes, and you can embed a GIF of the video right in your email. A short, personal walkthrough helps you stand out from the 30 other applicants they’re talking to.
How to Really Stand Out
Maya’s last question was the one every new grad is asking: the market is crowded, so what makes one candidate stand out?
Josh gave two answers. The first is to show value before you’re hired.
Imagine a candidate says, “Hey Josh, I know this is an interview and you weren’t asking for this, but I looked at your latest social media post and I want to show you how I would make it better.” I’d be like, “Wow, she’s working for us already.”
The second is networking. Build relationships with decision makers, especially at smaller agencies, and keep in touch. If the conversations go well, opportunities tend to present themselves, and you can skip a lot of the HR rigmarole.
“Show value before you’re hired.”
The Takeaway
None of this is complicated. Reach out. Build something you’re proud to share. Talk to people every week. Follow up like it matters, because it does. Maya was already doing more of this than she realized, and that’s exactly why the conversation was worth having.
If you’re a student or new grad trying to break into agency life and have a question we didn’t cover, send it to hello@bigredjelly.com. We love talking with people who are building something, whether that’s a brand, a business, or a career.
Frequently Asked Questions About Landing an Agency Job
How should a new grad start an agency job search?
Start before you graduate. Reaching out to people in the industry already puts you ahead of most classmates. Build a portfolio site on your own domain, set a goal of two or three conversations a week, and follow up after every interview.
Do I need my own website to get an agency job?
A portfolio site on your own domain helps you stand out, and Wix, Squarespace, and WordPress are all worth a look. WordPress is harder to learn, but over 40% of websites run on it, so knowing it can be a career advantage. Don’t get talked into the upsells when you buy your domain.
Is it better to start at an agency or in-house?
Josh’s view is that younger professionals learn about 10 times more at an agency but are about three times more stressed. Reverse engineer your career from where you want to be in 10 years. Many people spend three to eight years at an agency and then move in-house for more work-life balance.
How can students network effectively?
Use your student status. Ask professors, family, community members, and agency professionals to let you pick their brain, and aim for two or three conversations a week. End each one by asking who else you should meet. On LinkedIn, connect with intention, find common ground, engage with their posts first, and then make the ask.
What should I do after a job interview?
Use a one-two punch. Send a thank-you email right after the call, reattaching your resume and mentioning a moment that stood out. Send a second note a day or two later that builds on something they said. A short Loom video can also help you stand out.
How can I stand out from other candidates?
Show value before you’re hired, for example by sharing how you would improve one of the agency’s recent social posts. Also build relationships with decision makers, especially at smaller agencies, and keep in touch.






